Why won’t they speak up?

Have you ever been in a meeting where the senior person tells everyone that they like to be challenged, but the first time it happens (and the second and third), that’s not what people actually experience? They don’t necessarily get told off or totally ignored – it may be more of a polite acknowledgment or even a thank you but then the leader disagrees, says how it will be and puts the point aside … and moves on, then wonders why nobody pushes back on anything.
Sound familiar?
If our cartoon made you smile a little wryly, we suspect it’s because you recognise the situation. You might have found yourself on one side or the other at some point in your career… we know we have.
The interesting thing is that the leader often genuinely means it when they ask people to speak up. They don't think they're discouraging anyone. In their mind, they've invited challenge, listened to a different opinion and made a decision. Job done. What they don’t always see is their team isn’t responding to the invitation, they’re responding to what happened the last time somebody accepted it.
People take their cue from how we behave rather than what we say we want them to do.
The trouble with asking for honesty

Let’s imagine a manager who's become frustrated because their team rarely contributes ideas in meetings. They're a capable bunch of people, but getting an opinion out of them is beginning to feel like extracting teeth. The silence is deafening when an idea is invited.
A couple of months ago, the manager decided to do something about it. They announced that they want everyone to be more open, more willing to question things and much less worried about getting it wrong.
Excellent move. We're off. 😊
A few minutes later, someone suggested changing the way the team handled its weekly reports. Perhaps they could simplify them, save everyone a bit of time and stop producing quite so many spreadsheets that nobody seems to read.
The manager, with a look and a raise of the eyebrows, responded, "Yes, I can see why you'd suggest that, but this is how senior management wants the information, so let’s move on."
Perfectly reasonable, you might think.
The problem is that the person who spoke up had just learned that offering an idea wasn’t necessarily worth the effort. And everyone else had clocked it too. Without another word being said, the ‘real’ message had been received.
Worse still, everyone still had to produce the seventeen spreadsheets, three of which may possibly be read by an actual human being!
Oh… And the manager is still wondering why the team doesn't show more initiative.
Fiona still winces at a memory from earlier in her career, when she was working inside a large organisation with a Managing Director who had a reputation, fairly earned by most accounts, for being formidable.
In a workshop, she was standing at the front of the room talking the group through the change curve, the idea that when organisation go through change, morale and performance usually dip before they improve because people need to let go of the old way of doing things before finding their feet in the new one.
However, the MD interrupted to say that it wasn’t like that around here AND they didn’t dip.
Fiona remembers standing there, pen in hand, wishing the ground would swallow her up.
This was a leader who had told his people he wanted them to challenge him, and he was shutting down a well-established psychological theory within seconds of it being raised in front of everyone. There was no curiosity and everyone in the room saw the contradiction.
People notice far more than we realise

To be fair, this leader was trying to be honest, that he valued honesty and wanted people to push back. A lot of the leaders we work with feel the same way. What he couldn’t see was the difference between what he intended and what the impact was. The contradictory behaviour on his part that his team actually experienced.
In our book, Your Team is Your Mirror, we describe the way teams adapt to the emotional weather their leader creates, to what is rewarded, tolerated and what feels safe or risky, in order to succeed, survive and belong. A team that has watched one colleague’s challenge brushed aside doesn’t need a memo to work out the rules. The silence that follows isn’t disengagement or a shortage of ideas; it’s the team reflecting back what it has learned about what the leader really wants.
And that can be a really uncomfortable realisation. The very behaviour we're frustrated by in other people may be partly a response to something we're doing ourselves.
Saying you want challenge is the easy part - it's what happens after someone speaks up that matters
Anyone can say challenge is welcome but fewer leaders behave like it is when they’re actually being challenged. It’s that moment, rather than the invitation to challenge, which people remember. Amy Edmondson’s work on psychological safety suggests senior leaders tend to overestimate how safe their people feel speaking up. The more senior you become the more carefully filtered the feedback reaching you tends to be. Timothy Clark describes challenger safety as the last and most demanding stage of psychological safety - the point where people feel able to question decisions, challenge assumptions and disagree, even with those who have more authority than they do.
And, in our experience, it’s also the most fragile because a single dismissive response can undo months of encouragement – the words don't even need to be spoken, a frown or a quizzical look or a shake of the head can do it.
Think about the last time someone disagreed with you. Perhaps you were under pressure, running late or convinced you'd already thought the issue through.
What happened?
Did you ask them to explain their thinking? Or did you find yourself preparing your response before they'd finished speaking?
We're human. And when we're busy, tired or feeling challenged ourselves, our reactions aren't always quite as thoughtful as we'd like them to be.
What strikes us about the leader in our cartoon is that he isn’t hostile at all. “I hear you but let’s not get sidetracked” sounds reasonable, yet the team hears the second half of the sentence more loudly than the first. It’s rarely the dramatic reactions that close a conversation. More often it’s the brisk moving on, the slight change in tone or the point that is acknowledged and then parked.
So, what can we do differently?

The most useful response to a challenge is often the simplest one, a genuine “thank you, tell me more,” said with a face and tone that match the words. If you need time to think, it helps to say it out loud because silence from the most senior person in the room is rarely read as reflection and we can all be creative about what silence means!
And when somebody raises something difficult, naming what you’ll do with it keeps the door open, even when the honest answer is that you can’t change it right now because nothing discourages the next challenge like the sense that the last one disappeared.
The simple point is that we can help people feel their contribution was worth making even if we don’t agree with every suggestion they make.
What we do think matters most is that people leave the conversation knowing they've been heard, rather than wishing they'd kept their mouth shut.
If you suspect your team has already learned to keep their reservations to themselves, a brave step is to ask someone you trust a very specific question, something like “What’s one thing I do that makes it harder for you to tell me the truth?” and then resist the urge to explain, clarify or defend yourself while they answer. It’s hard to do well and both of us have asked these kinds of questions in the past and then promptly talked over the reply. ☹
For the MD mentioned earlier, the curve was never the problem, and neither was the dip. The team would have gone through it whatever anyone drew on the flipchart. What mattered was whether they felt able to go through it honestly, with a leader who wanted to know how it was really going, which is something no amount of creative wall hanging can fix.
When someone on your team last disagreed with you, what do you think they saw on your face in the second before you replied?

If this story felt a little too familiar, you’ll find much more about it in our book, Your Team is Your Mirror, including a whole chapter on making it safe for people to tell you the truth.



Comments